🔍 Read the full analysis: The AI Investment Rush: Few Clear Returns Beyond Tech on ThorstenMeyerAI.com
Get hardware and tech essentials delivered free with Prime
- Fast, free delivery on millions of items
- Prime Video, Amazon Music and more included
- Member-only deals all year
TL;DR
Apollo economist Torsten Slok says broad corporate data show no clear financial payoff from AI outside the technology sector, while major companies commit heavily to data centers, chips and cloud capacity. The finding describes aggregate trends, not proof that AI has produced no gains anywhere: specific customer-support and retail deployments have shown measurable results, but many firms report no productivity impact so far.
Apollo Global Management chief economist Torsten Slok said an analysis published October 24 found no clear aggregate financial payoff from AI outside the technology sector, as companies continue to commit large sums to computing infrastructure. The finding is based on broad measures of revenue per worker, profit margins and productivity; it does not establish that every non-tech company or AI project has failed to benefit.
Apollo’s charts compare the Magnificent Seven technology companies with the other 493 members of the S&P 500. Revenue per worker and profit margins have risen for the seven, while the corresponding measures for the other companies have remained broadly flat, according to the note. Apollo also cites San Francisco Federal Reserve productivity measures that it says show no sign yet of AI lifting productivity growth.
The investment commitments are substantial. Meta’s October 22 quarterly filing lists about $355.73 billion in leases not yet started and $454.52 billion in non-cancelable contractual commitments, largely related to cloud capacity, servers and network equipment. It also reports up to $14.72 billion in contingent cloud-capacity purchases. The totals are not all AI spending: the filing includes other activities, including Reality Labs hardware.
Meta reported $34.91 billion in capital expenditures for the third quarter and narrowed its 2026 spending forecast to $135 billion to $145 billion. Operating cash flow was $32.79 billion, leaving free cash flow at negative $2.12 billion, compared with positive $10.6 billion a year earlier. Separately, the source reports that SpaceX borrowed $40 billion to buy AI chips, underscoring the scale of financing involved in the buildout.
Infographic 01 · The “zero” in numbers
What “zero financial payoff” actually measures.
Apollo’s headline rests on five charts. Here are their numbers, and what they can and cannot prove.
Who pays for AI? Share of spending by the top 10% of firms
Ramp customer data via Apollo · non-AI categories in grey for comparison
Spending is concentrated in every category, not only AI; AI is the most extreme.
What the five charts do and do not show
shown not shown
- Shown: revenue per worker and margins rising for the 7 tech giants, flat for the other 493
- Shown: no AI lift yet in US productivity statistics (San Francisco Fed TFP, output per hour)
- Shown: AI spending sits in few, mostly venture-funded firms (Ramp, 85,000+ US businesses)
- Not shown: that AI caused the gap; rates, tariffs and wages move the same lines
- Not shown: gains inside single functions, which can cancel out in an average
- Not shown: the S&P 493 itself in the Ramp data; those are Ramp’s customers
“The AI story will be decided in the S&P 493, not the Mag 7.”Torsten Slok, Apollo chief economist, 24 Oct 2026 (opinion)
Sources: Apollo Daily Spark (24 Oct 2026) with charts by Bloomberg, Macrobond, SF Fed, BLS and Ramp; Apollo (20 Oct 2026); Ramp AI Index. Values with ≈ are read off Apollo’s charts. Assessment: Thorsten Meyer.
Powered by Thorsten Meyer AI
The Gap Between AI Spending and Returns
The gap matters because companies are committing money to infrastructure before broad, measurable gains are evident in the productivity and financial measures Apollo examined. If spending grows faster than the value businesses can capture, it could weigh on margins and raise questions about how projects are financed. Meta’s filing shows the scale of its future obligations, but commitments spread over multiple years are not the same as cash already spent or a direct measure of AI losses.
The picture is not uniformly negative. The source cites research finding customer-support agents resolved 14% more issues per hour with AI assistance, rising to 34% for novice agents, and retail experiments with sales results ranging from no increase to a 16.3% increase depending on the workflow. These are specific settings, not evidence that the same gains apply across industries. The immediate issue for business leaders and investors is whether such local improvements can become durable returns large enough to justify ongoing computing and financing costs.
Products Worth Considering

Apple MacBook Pro 14.2-inch with M5 Pro, 15-Core CPU, 16-Core GPU, 24GB Memory, 2TB SSD, Wi-Fi 7, Space Black

Apple MacBook Pro 16-inch (M1 Pro, 10‑core CPU, 16‑core GPU, 16GB RAM, 512GB SSD) – Silver

Ledger Flex Crypto Wallet with 2.8-Inch E Ink Touchscreen
As an affiliate, we earn on qualifying purchases.
What Apollo’s Aggregate Measures Show
Apollo’s October 24 note, titled “No Signs of AI Payoff Outside the Tech Sector,” was circulated more widely in the following days. Its comparisons show the seven largest technology companies at roughly $780,000 in inflation-adjusted revenue per employee in the third quarter of 2026, against about $525,000 for the other 493 S&P 500 companies. The note says the latter group’s measure has remained in a similar range since 2021, while the seven companies’ profit margins rose to roughly 30%, compared with about 10% for the rest.
Those comparisons describe company-level outcomes, not a controlled test isolating AI’s effect. A flat average can conceal firms that gained or lost, and the figures cannot by themselves separate AI from factors such as labor costs, tariffs or interest rates. Apollo also cites Ramp spending data from a platform with more than 85,000 U.S. business customers: the top 10% of firms accounted for 99.5% of spending on model serving and inference, 99% of neocloud spending and 95.6% of spending on OpenAI and Anthropic. That customer sample is not identical to the S&P 500.
“Artificial intelligence “has delivered zero financial payoff to corporate America outside of tech.””
— Torsten Slok, Apollo chief economist, as quoted in the October 24 note
What the Payoff Data Cannot Establish
The available figures do not isolate the causal effect of AI on company revenue, margins or productivity, and the source does not provide a controlled comparison across firms. It is unclear how much of the technology sector’s stronger performance is attributable to AI rather than other business or market factors. Nor does Apollo’s 493-company average reveal how many individual companies have achieved gains that are offset by costs or weaker results elsewhere.
The source also reports that 83% of nearly 9,000 executives said AI had not affected productivity so far, with an average estimated effect of 0.2% a year. The survey’s results do not establish what productivity effects may emerge later. Meta’s listed commitments are obligations across different categories and time periods, not a forecast of spending in a single year; the precise portion tied to AI is not specified. Claims about credit conditions and future infrastructure spending likewise do not show whether the resulting investment will earn an adequate return.
Spending Plans and Productivity Evidence
Investors and companies will be watching upcoming earnings, capital-spending forecasts and productivity data for evidence that AI deployments are generating returns beyond the technology firms selling computing and models. Meta’s stated 2026 capital-spending range and its future contractual obligations provide measures to track, but neither alone shows whether the spending will produce profitable services or efficiencies.
Further evidence will need to distinguish broad company averages from outcomes in particular workflows, and infrastructure costs from the value captured by customers. For now, the reporting supports a narrower conclusion: large-scale AI investment is confirmed, while a widespread financial payoff outside technology is not yet visible in the cited aggregate measures. Both the timing and scale of any broader return remain unsettled.
Key Questions
What did Apollo mean by “zero financial payoff”?
Economist Torsten Slok used the phrase for aggregate indicators showing that revenue per worker and profit margins were rising for seven major technology companies but broadly flat for the other 493 S&P 500 companies. It is an interpretation of those trends, not proof that every non-tech AI project has returned nothing.
How much has Meta committed to future spending?
Meta’s filing lists about $355.73 billion in leases not yet started, $454.52 billion in non-cancelable contractual commitments and up to $14.72 billion in contingent cloud-capacity purchases. The categories cover multiple years and are not all AI-related.
Have companies reported measurable benefits from AI?
Some specific applications have shown gains in the cited material, including higher customer-support issue resolution and sales increases in certain retail experiments. Results vary by task, and those examples do not show that similar returns are widespread.
Does Apollo’s analysis prove AI has not raised productivity?
No. The note says the cited broad productivity measures show no sign of an AI-driven increase so far. Aggregate data may miss gains in particular firms or tasks, and they do not determine what future effects will be.
Source: ThorstenMeyerAI.com
